Wasswa Shafik [0000-0002-9320-3186]School of Digital Science, Universiti Brunei Darussalam, Gadong, BE1410, Brunei DarussalamAbstract: Scientific African continues to avail scientific research and review articles available not only for the African continent but for the entire globe through its ten interdisciplinary scopes since its commencement, with its first volume published in December 2018, with a critical evaluation of a developing academic publication spanning six years. As of the current published literature, including the in-progress March volume 2024, the journal has produced 58 quality research in Social Sciences and Policy (SOC), 101 under Physical Sciences (PHY), 129 in Mathematics (MAT), Life and Health Sciences (LIF) availed the highest number of published article among others with 443, 222 in Information Technology and Engineering (ITE), 297 under Environmental and Geosciences (ENV), 67 under Economics and Business (ECO), 94 in Conservation and Sustainability Studies (CON), 157 under Chemistry, and 240 under Agriculture and Food Security (AGF). The journal has eight members on its advisory board and two managing editors. LIF has the biggest number of editors amongst the six scopes that present its editors, including ITE, ENV, CON, CHE, and AGF. Currently, only two editorials have been seen during the literature mining, the first showing better ways on how an abstract can be written honestly and effectively in scientific writing in volume 6 of November 2019. The other detailed an innovative biopolymer-based composite addition. This study scrutinizes the journal’s evolution, analyzing its thematic focus, publication consistency, and the quality of disseminated information by answering some critical research questions the research community can raise. Evaluating the editorial board’s makeup, the study evaluates the rigor and transparency of the peer-review process. The study scrutinizes the journal’s impact, assessing citation numbers and its influence inside the academic realm. Assessing author diversity and geographic reach, it dives into the journal’s inclusion and worldwide appeal. Furthermore, it probes into the journal’s flexibility to develop trends and developments within its subject. The study highlights reader interaction, feedback methods, and ethical norms as key features under study. Finally, it analyzes strategies for sustainable growth and future trajectory, incorporating a full examination of the journal’s progress, strengths, and prospective areas for enhancement within its initial five-year trajectory.Keywords: Editorial Board, Social Sciences and Policy, Physical Sciences, Mathematics, Life and Health Sciences, Information Technology and Engineering, Environmental and Geosciences, Economics and Business, Conservation and Sustainability Studies, Chemistry, Agriculture and Food Security, Quality Peer ReviewIntroductionScientific African11https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/scientific-african, instituted in December 2018 with its first volume, symbolizes multidisciplinary scientific investigation, surpassing geographical limits to distribute knowledge emanating from African content worldwide focusing on different the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals22https://sdgs.un.org/goals [1-5]. The six-year trip exemplifies a dedication to a wide range of areas, as demonstrated by the publication of research covering ten transdisciplinary fields [6]. The journal has consistently demonstrated a strong commitment to featuring scholarly works that have a significant impact not just in Africa but also in the global scientific community, covering a wide range of topics from Social Sciences and Policy (SOC) to Agriculture and Food Security (AFS) [7]. The wide range of volumes covering various fields has created a favorable environment for enhancing worldwide scientific discussions and comprehension.Despite its notable progress, the journal’s editorial contributions have been quite small, providing only two editorials with limited insights [8]. Nevertheless, these articles have offered extremely helpful advice on abstract formulation and introduced groundbreaking biopolymer-based composites, suggesting the possibility of enhanced content and innovation within the publication [9]. This study goes beyond just looking at numerical figures. It carefully examines the thematic evolution of Scientific African, how consistently it publishes, and the quality of the material it shares. This article explores the meticulousness of the editorial board and the openness of its peer-review procedure, providing insight into the academic integrity and criteria of the journal [10-13].This assessment also encompasses the effects and sway of the publication, including citation metrics and academic acclaim within the scientific community. The study evaluates the variety of authors and the extent of contributions from different geographic locations, shedding light on the journal’s inclusiveness and worldwide popularity. The investigation explores the journal’s capacity to adjust to evolving trends, its engagement with readers, and its commitment to ethical principles. This thorough examination not only provides a detailed comprehension of the development of Scientific African but also proposes practical approaches for achieving long-term growth and improvement, outlining a path for ongoing academic excellence and impact.Study MotivationThe pursuit of this study involves a composite combination of several research factors, including an intense curiosity that drives the research community into unexplored territories, a strong enthusiasm that ignites our search for knowledge, and a profound desire to make a meaningful contribution to society that propels us onward. This undertaking presents both cognitive obstacles and the potential for personal and research advancement across the continent, fostering a deep sense of satisfaction derived from the pursuit of innovative breakthroughs. This study looks at identifying critical and theoretical-practical implementation of answers to research questions to real-life challenges that affect Africa based on the journal research scope, motivated by a steadfast dedication to innovation and resolving problems. The act of working together and forming connections within an ever-changing environment enhances the experience, providing chances for both personal growth and shared development. In the end, this combination of motives becomes intertwined, leading to a persistent quest for knowledge, progress, and meaningful contributions to African society.The rest of this study is structured in six sections. Section 2 presents the literature search and selection criteria, including the research objectives and research questions. Section 3 presents the journal research scope, including SOC, Physical Sciences (PHY), Mathematics (MAT), Life and Health Sciences (LIF), Information Technology and Engineering (ITE), Environmental and Geosciences (ENV), Economics and Business (ECO), Conservation and Sustainability Studies (CON), and Agriculture and Food Security (AGF). Section 4 illustrates the research Insights and discussions by answering the presented research question to justify the study objectives. Section 5 shows the significant takeaways, recommendations, and limitations of this study. Finally, Section 6 presents the study conclusion.Literature Search and Selection CriteriaTo have a deep understanding of the Scientific African content and more specific facts of the journal publications, 97% of the references are taken from the journal, and 3% are attained from another journal for comparison purposes as some research questions present require balanced coverage. Since the journal is open access, the utilized literature can be accessed fully, and the articles of 3% have been selected based on the validity of the journal scope and content quality.Research ObjectivesThe main aim of this search is summarized in the following.To find out the specific range and emphasis of Scientific African.To critically understand what the frequency of publication for the issues is.To know what the overall caliber of the published research articles is.To discover the editorial board members and existing facts based on the journal website and their qualifications and areas of expertise.To find out to which extent this Scientific African citation is in other scholarly works.To check the author’s exhibition of diversity in terms of their geographic areas, institutions, and backgrounds.To investigate what the demographic of the readers could be. Is there ongoing participation, discourse, or input on published articles?To discover if any measures have been implemented to ensure the journal’s long-term viability and expansion.Research QuestionsTo tackle this research objective effectively, this study uses the following questions to guide the study discussion.Research Question (1) on the scope and focus: Is there a specific scope, and has it continually adhered to its topic focus, or has it broadened over time? This question will be able to provide specific answers to the first objective of the study.Research Question (2) on publication frequency and consistency: Has the continually adhered to its topic focus, or has it broadened over time? This question will provide the research community with the options on whether the journal publication frequencies allow their publication options.Research Question (3) on the quality of content: Do the published research and review articles exhibit thorough research, compelling arguments, and substantiation through dependable data? To test the quality of the published article, we have compared selected samples from other journals of the same years of existence based on a few selection criteria.Research Question (4) focusing on the editorial board and review process: How does the peer-review process operate in Scientific African? Does it adhere to strict standards and provide clear visibility? This question will provide the public confidence and research results in acceptance and trust based on the board the journal provides.Research question (5) on the impact and citations: What is the impact factor or other measures that indicate its effect in the journal field scope? This will increase impact the journal’s growth and diversity in different scopes that involve health and agriculture.Research question (6) on the author’s diversity and geographic reach: Does the publication solicit submissions from researchers across various geographic regions beyond Africa?Research questions (7) on reader engagement and feedback: Are there mechanisms implemented to collect feedback and enhance the content depending on readers’ suggestions? This generally applies in cases when the research registers any ethical research compliant or research content.Research questions (8) on long-term sustainability and growth: Is there any indication of a positive trend in terms of reputation, submissions, and influence? Examining these inquiries, the research community can develop a thorough comprehension of Scientific African’s advancement, merits, and potential locations for enhancement, particularly over its initial five years of functioning.Journal Research ScopeWithin this section, a description of the research scope is presented. The current publication demonstrates publication matrices from the first volume in 2018 to the current in-progress March volume of 2024, as depicted.Social Sciences and PolicyThis scope focuses on and examines human behavior, societal structures, policies, and their effects on communities [14]. This scope encompasses a study that investigates diverse aspects of African societies, including cultural dynamics, political systems, economic development, public health policies, education, and governance structures [15]. The objective is to examine the distinct difficulties encountered by African countries, evaluating the effectiveness of strategies aimed at tackling socio-economic inequalities, improving healthcare availability, implementing educational changes, and understanding the cultural aspects that influence African societies [17].This scope frequently encompasses research that elucidates the interconnectedness of social, political, and economic elements, with the goal of offering valuable insights that help shape the development and execution of policies to improve African communities. An illustration may be a research endeavor examining the influence of a certain healthcare policy in an African nation, evaluating its efficacy in tackling public health issues and its ramifications on society and governance [18]. Studies may investigate universal topics such as migration patterns, global economic policies, social disparities, or the ramifications of technological breakthroughs on societies. The purpose of these investigations is to enhance our comprehension of human behavior, societal structures, and the creation of policies that go beyond regional limits [19]. They aim to stimulate discussions and provide guidance for policy frameworks that advance social fairness, sustainable development, and enhanced quality of life for people globally. Table 1 presents the current publication matrices of SOC; it demonstrates that it is currently the least published scope amongst the ten scopes.Table 1: Publication Frequency for Scientific African Social Sciences and Policy (Mar, March; Dec, December; Jul, July; Sept, September and Nov, November)