Benggang erosion leads to significant soil and water loss in the red soil hilly regions of southern China, with shear strength identified as a crucial indicator of the stability of collapsing walls. This study first undertook a bibliometric analysis of 146 relevant publications sourced from China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) and Web of Science (WoS) covering the period from 2000 to 2025. Subsequently, 40 publications containing high-quality experimental data were selected for meta-analysis. This analysis systematically quantified the effects of multiple factors on shear strength and ranked their respective weights. The findings indicated that the bibliometric analysis demonstrated exponential growth in research focused on soil shear strength of Benggang. The Journal of Soil and Water Conservation and Catena were identified as the leading Chinese and international journals, respectively, in terms of publication volume. The research teams directed by Yanhe Huang at Fujian Agriculture and Forestry University and Shuwen Ding at Huazhong Agricultural University constituted the two principal collaboration networks. An analysis of keyword co-occurrence and thematic evolution revealed that ”influencing factors” consistently constituted a central theme within the research. Meta-analysis revealed the contribution of multiple factors to soil shear strength was ranked as follows: soil moisture content > plant roots > cementing agents > dry-wet cycling > soil texture. It was found that soil moisture content exhibits a distinct threshold; specifically, within the range of 5% to 30%, it has a significant effect on cohesion force (effect value = 1.243) and the internal friction angle (effect value = 1.088). Beyond 30%, the effects diminish sharply, resulting in effect values of 0.267 and 0.170, respectively. The increase in the number of dry-wet cycling results in a cumulative deterioration effect. When the frequency of dry-wet cycling is fewer than five, the cohesion force is only weakly affected, exhibiting an effect value of 0.167. However, as the frequency of dry-wet cycling increases to the range of five to ten, there is a significant reduction in the soil shear strength, with the effect values for the cohesion force and the internal friction angle reaching 1.749 and 1.863, respectively. Additionally, root densitys enhance shear strength through root length and surface area, positioning them just below soil moisture content in terms of contribution. These findings provide a theoretical foundation for the prevention and management of disasters related to the collapsing walls of Benggang.