Biodiversity in urban environments is often underestimated, especially in tropical regions such as Ecuador. This study provides the most comprehensive inventory of amphibians and reptiles recorded in the remnant forests and urban gardens of Guayaquil, the largest and most industrially developed city in Ecuador. Located on the Pacific coast and close to two important biodiversity hotspots (the Tropical Andes and Tumbes–Chocó–Magdalena), Guayaquil has experienced significant urban expansion, fragmenting its unique ecosystems, such as tropical dry forests and mangroves. Our research combines over 16 years (2008–2024) of field monitoring efforts, museum specimens, and literature review, documenting 65 species (21 amphibians, 44 reptiles). This inventory includes introduced species, resilient taxa that are adapted to urban environments, and sensitive species that are affected by urban pressure. Notably, species such as Hemidactylus frenatus, Anolis sagrei, and Aquarana catesbeiana thrive in these modified landscapes, displaying ecological plasticity, whereas highly sensitive species, including Alopoglossus festae and Lepidoblepharis buchwaldi, are restricted to less disturbed areas. The study also highlights the presence of rare species with little previous documentation, such as Atractus microrhynchus, Caecilia tenuissima, Chironius flavopictus, and Drymobius rhombifer. In addition, expansions in the known distributions of several species in the Guayaquil area were recorded, including Caiman crocodilus and Clelia clelia, which emphasizes the ecological relevance of this region. This study highlights the importance of continuous monitoring and ecological studies to support urban biodiversity conservation, emphasizing that Guayaquil’s natural areas are essential refuges for herpetofauna amid urban expansion.