Intraspecific trait variation (ITV) is critical for plant adaptation, particularly under increasing drought. ITV arises from phenotypic plasticity and genetic differentiation, so identifying its sources improves understanding of population responses to drought. This study investigates how climate and genetics shape ITV and drought responses in Andropogon gerardi, a foundational Great Plains grass. To quantify climatic determinants of ITV, we conducted a common‐garden greenhouse experiment with 25 A. gerardi populations spanning wide temperature (4–21°C; Minnesota–Texas) and precipitation (350–1400 mm yr⁻¹; Colorado–North Carolina) gradients, measuring 17 functional traits. To test drought as a selective pressure, eight populations across a precipitation gradient (470–1350 mm yr⁻¹) were exposed to experimental drought (15% moisture vs. 30% control). Populations were also genotyped to assess the genetic basis of ITV, and greenhouse–field trait comparisons were used to separate genetic and environmental effects. We hypothesized that climate of origin, particularly precipitation, predicts ITV: dry populations would express drought‐adaptive traits (higher water‐use efficiency, shorter stature), whereas wet populations would exhibit competitive traits (greater height, biomass). We further predicted that drought would reduce growth and delay flowering, with stronger effects in wet populations, and that trait variation would correspond with genetic differentiation. Precipitation and aridity were the strongest predictors of ITV. Principal component analyses revealed that wet populations displayed competitive traits (taller stature, larger leaves), while arid populations showed drought‐adaptive traits (higher water‐use efficiency, reduced stature). Under drought, wet populations exhibited greater declines in biomass and photosynthesis, indicating drought as a key selective force. Congruent genetic and trait PCAs confirmed a strong genetic basis for ITV, and consistent greenhouse–field patterns reinforced genetic control. Overall, ITV in A. gerardi is primarily shaped by precipitation through coordinated, genetically based trait responses, offering a predictive framework for grassland adaptation under future climate change.