not-yet-known not-yet-known not-yet-known unknown This commentary critically reviews the 2024 article ”Kirchhoff meets Johnson: In pursuit of unconditionally secure communication” by Ertugrul Basar, focusing on claims regarding the originality, security, and energy efficiency of thermal noise-based secure communication systems. The article presents the Kirchhoff-law-Johnson-noise (KLJN) key exchange scheme and wireless noise modulation as breakthroughs in security; this review clarifies their historical foundation, practical limitations, and security vulnerabilities. Key issues discussed include proper attribution to pioneering work by Kish (2005–2006), feasibility of unconditional security for wireless adaptations, and exaggerated claims of low-power operation. The aim is to contextualize this field’s evolution for engineering audiences and stimulate more precise scholarship and realistic expectations for future research directions.