Flow matters: Unravelling the interactive influences of flow alterations
and non-native trout on vulnerable galaxiids
Abstract
Understanding the interactive effects of non-native species and
alterations to flow regimes is important to combat threats to freshwater
communities. Low-flow conditions may either exacerbate or offset
influences of non-natives but the mechanisms determining the direction
are poorly understood. We evaluated how stream drying affected
interactions between vulnerable native non-migratory galaxiids and
non-native trout in Aotearoa - New Zealand. We electrofished (December
– March) paired perennial and drying reaches containing galaxiids (
Galaxias vulgaris and G. paucispondylus) to compare
abundance and growth rates in streams with high abundance (n=2), low
abundance (n=2) or no brown trout (n=3; Salmo trutta). Low flows
greatly reduced trout abundance and size, likely reducing predatory
threats to galaxiids since risk is size-related. Galaxiid densities were
consistently lower in drying compared to perennial reaches of troutless
streams. However, galaxiids were less affected by low flows than trout,
setting the scene for an interaction between trout and low flow. In
streams with high numbers of trout, galaxiid numbers were very low in
perennial reaches, whereas they were moderate in drying reaches. That
meant galaxiid numbers increased with decreasing flow in streams with
many trout, an indirect positive effect, although their abundance never
reached the high levels of trout-free perennial reaches. In low-density
trout streams, there were no clear differences in galaxiid abundance
between reaches of different flow type. Thus, the effects of trout on
galaxiids depended on the flow regime, likely driven by harsh low-flow
conditions suppressing large trout, which were more sensitive to low
flow than galaxiids. Growth advantages for galaxiids possibly enhanced
this interaction because galaxiids grew fastest when trout were present
at low densities. Overall, although low-flow conditions likely reduced
predatory effects of non-natives, populations of natives were also
suppressed by low flow. Such interactive effects of flow reduction are
likely common and appear controlled by relative vulnerability and
size-structured interactions. Balancing maintenance of natural flows
with minimising effects of non-native sports fish poses a difficult
challenge, but managers should aim to both protect natural flow regimes
to maintain suitable fish habitat, and actively manage non-native
species in harmful situations to conserve native fish.