Sporobolus cryptandrus, a North American C4 grass, is a recent invader in some European sandy grasslands, particularly in Central Europe (Hungary), where it severely threatens native plant communities. As allelopathy has been documented for other Sporobolus species, we tested whether litter from S. cryptandrus has a different effect on the germination and seedling emergence of native grassland species compared to native grass litter. The germination and seedling growth of nine native grassland species and S. cryptandrus were examined in three treatments: without litter (control), with native litter and with S. cryptandrus litter. We hypothesized that: (i) litter has an overall negative effect on seedling germination and establishment compared to no litter; (ii) Sporobolus litter has a significantly more negative effect compared to native grass litter on seedling germination and establishment; and that (iii) the effect of litter type is highly species-specific. Our results showed that the presence of litter did not negatively affect germination and establishment across species, in fact, seedling length even increased in the presence of litter. Contrary to our expectation, Sporobolus litter negatively affected the germination and seedling growth only in the case of Bromus tectorum. For most of the other species, the effects of native and Sporobolus litter were highly similar, suggesting that litter influenced seedlings primarily through physical rather than chemical mechanisms, such as allelopathy. However, the clear suppression of B. tectorum by Sporobolus litter also suggests a potential allelopathic effect. According to our findings, litter effects are species-specific. Moreover, the suppression of B. tectorum by Sporobolus litter could offer novel insights for managing B. tectorum, a problematic invader in North America. Future research should explore the long-term effects of the litter of Sporobolus species in guiding restoration actions and invasive species management.