Although uncommonly encountered, dual atrioventricular nodal non-reentrant tachycardia (DAVNNRT) is a well described arrhythmia that can manifest in patients with dual atrioventricular nodal pathways physiology. This arrhythmia is characterized on ECG by a single P wave followed by two conducted QRS complexes, and on intracardiac EGMs by a single atrial electrogram followed by two separate His deflections and ventricular electrograms. Our case demonstrates a rare case of “triple atrioventricular non-reentrant tachycardia” in which a patient was found to have 3 distinct AV nodal pathways and multiple “triple fire responses”, both on surface ECG and intracardiac electrograms.