Biodiversity hotspots are often found in areas with high precipitation or diverse microhabitats. For plants, geographic areas with high soil variability tend to have high species richness or functional trait diversity. Serpentine soil is thought to have driven the diversification of numerous plant lineages, and many plant taxa show phenotypic variability across soil types. Precipitation can increase the effects of soil type on trait differences across soil types, such that trait differences are greater in wetter geographic areas. However, this has been examined only for growth and vegetative traits. We used a greenhouse common garden to characterize variation in reproductive phenology for a serpentine tolerator along a strong moisture gradient. We then evaluated if trait divergence changes with precipitation, and if the divergence in reproductive traits across soil types varies with precipitation. Furthermore, we conducted a water-limitation experiment and examined if water-limitation changes trait expression or divergence in trait expression. Finally, through a set of field observations we assessed if reproductive phenology and divergence in reproductive phenology differed between wetter and drier areas. We found strong effects of native precipitation regime on flowering phenology, and some support for the hypothesis that precipitation enhances divergence between plants growing on serpentine and non-serpentine soils both in the greenhouse common garden and in the field. Experimental water limitation in the greenhouse common garden resulted in reduced floral displays, phenological delays, and an increase in divergence across soil types for some traits. These results highlight the possibility that gene flow across soil types may be lower in wetter areas. In addition, they suggest that future drought may decrease the likelihood of gene flow across soil types, as well as plant reproductive potential via smaller floral displays.