Pediatric moderate aplastic anemia (MAA) lacks defined diagnostic criteria and a clear standard-of-care due to the limited knowledge of its pathophysiology and natural history. The approach to MAA has been historically inconsistent as the proposed survey demonstrates. To understand current diagnostic and management practices for patients with MAA, a survey was conducted among members of the North American Pediatric Aplastic Anemia Consortium (NAPAAC), including 104 providers across 57 institutions. The survey demonstrates broad variability regarding the working definition, diagnostic work-up, and therapeutic management of children with MAA. The diagnostic work-up and treatment options for children with MAA are largely driven by management guidelines for pediatric severe aplastic anemia (SAA). Treatment triggers, type of therapy, and outcomes varied widely among respondents. Curated next generation sequencing panels and whole exome/whole genome sequencing were included by only 55% and 9% of respondents, respectively which suggests the need to more broadly consider inherited bone marrow failure syndromes in the differential diagnosis for these patients. Effective and risk-adapted treatment for MAA requires a better understanding of the biology, natural history, and treatment outcomes for this heterogeneous population.