Introduction Cardioneuroablation (CNA) is a technique used to modulate cardiac parasympathetic tone in patients with sino-atrial (SA) and atrio-ventricular (AV) vagally mediated syncope. We describe the case of a patient who developed AV block after a first procedure of CNA, requiring a second procedure. Case presentation A 47-Year-old man presented with recurrent syncope (daily episodes) associated with high vagal tone conditions. An ECG monitoring showed frequent episodes of sinus bradycardia and sinus arrest, with pauses up to 17 seconds. AV node conduction impairment was never identified. A CNA procedure targeting the right superior and posterior ganglionated plexi (GPs), both from the left and right atrium, was performed with acute success. The subsequent night, repetitive episodes of AV block with normal sinus rate were observed. A second procedure was performed targeting the posteromedial left GP. Follow-up at 4 months showed no recurrent syncopal event and no bradyarrhythmia episode on the implantable loop recorder. Conclusion This case report demonstrates that ablation limited to the right superior and posterior GPs may not be enough for neurocardiogenic syncope and a more systematic approach, extending the ablation to the posteromedial left GP, should be considered.