Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics Table 2 Study characteristics
Author, year (total patients) study type MI/MS (N) Age (y/o) Age (y/o) Sex (female) (no, %) Sex (female) (no, %) Sex (female) (no, %) Sex (female) (no, %) BSA(m2) BMI (kg/m2) BSA(m2) BMI (kg/m2) Tumor Size (max diameter cm) Tumor Size (max diameter cm)
Tumor Histology and Location
Tumor Histology and Location
MI MS MI MI MI MS MI MS MI MS MI MS
Ravikumar, 2000 (n=5) Retrospective
2/3
33.5
43.3
2 (100)
2 (100)
2 (100)
2 (66.3)
NA
NA
NA
NA
Myxoma 2 (100%)
Myxoma 2 (66.3%) Chondrosarcoma 1 (33.3%)
Iribarne, 2010 (n=74) Retrospective
38/36
52.4±2.8
59.9±2.6
29 (76.3)
29 (76.3)
29 (76.3)
23 (63.8)
26.5±1
26.7±0.8
8.5±1.7
13.2±2.6
Left atrium 16 (44.4%) Right atrium 12 (33.3%) Aorta 4 (11.1%) Other 4 (11.1%) Myxoma 18 (50%) Papillary fibro. 8 (22.2%) Thrombus 3 (8.3%) Vascular malformation 4 (11.1%) Other 3 (8.3%) Left atrium 30 (79%) Right atrium 4 (10.5%) Aorta 3 (7.9%) Other 1 (2.6%) Myxoma 26 (68.4%) Papillary fibro. 5 (13.2%) Thrombus 4 (2.6%) Vascular malformation 1 (2.6%) Other 2 (5.3%)
Pineda, 2014 (n=39) Retrospective
22/17
62±17
57±12
18 (81.8)
18 (81.8)
18 (81.8)
12 (70.6)
NA
NA
7.5 (4-19.7)
7.5 (4-19.7)
Left atrium 22 (56.4%) Aortic valve 8 (20.5%) Right atrium 6 (15.4%) Left ventricle 2 (5.1%) Right ventricle 1 (2.6%) Myxoma 26 (66.7%) Papillary fibro. 9 (23.1%) Thrombus 4 (10.2%) Left atrium 22 (56.4%) Aortic valve 8 (20.5%) Right atrium 6 (15.4%) Left ventricle 2 (5.1%) Right ventricle 1 (2.6%) Myxoma 26 (66.7%) Papillary fibro. 9 (23.1%) Thrombus 4 (10.2%)
Shilling, 2012 (n=45) Retrospective
16/29
53.1±15.2
58.8±11.4
58.8±11.4
11 (69)
21 (72)
21 (72)
34.6±6.8
28.6±5.3
NA
NA
Left atrium 16 (100%) Myxoma 16 (100%) Left atrium 29 (100%) Myxoma 29 (100%)
Yang, 2015 (n=93) Retrospective
49/44
47.7±13
51.2±12.1
51.2±12.1
25 (51)
26 (59)
26 (59)
23.2±3.6
23.5±3.8
4.8
4.3
Left atrium 45 (91.8%) Right atrium 4 (8.1%) Myxoma 49 (100%) Left atrium 39 (88.6%) Right atrium 5 (11.3%) Myxoma 44 (100%)
Sawaki, 2015 (n=23) Retrospective
7/16
68.7±7.8
62.6±18.1
62.6±18.1
3 (43.3)
12 (75%)
12 (75%)
23.4±2.4
23.9±4.1
16±9
16.7±8.9
Left atrium 6 (86%) Right atrium 1 (14%) Myxoma 7 (100%) Left atrium 13 (81%) Right atrium 2 (13%) Other 1 (6%) Myxoma 12 (75%) Thrombus 2 (13%) Hemangioma 1 (6%) Hamartoma 1 (6%)
Lee, 2016 (n=146) Retrospective
63/83
51.5±14.6
54.8±13.9
54.8±13.9
54 (86)
51 (61)
51 (61)
23±2.9
23.1±2.7
3.7±1.8
3.5±1.5
Left atrium 60 (95%) Right atrium 3 (5%) Myxoma 63 (100%) Left atrium 75 (90%) Right atrium 5 (6%) Left ventricle 2 (3%) Right ventricle 1 (1%) Myxoma 83 (100%)
Moss, 2016 (n=69) Retrospective
30/39
55.1±13.1
59.5±13.4
59.5±13.4
23 (76.7)
27 (69.2)
27 (69.2)
29±7.5
28.6±6.1
NA
NA
Left atrium 30 (100%)
Left atrium 39 (100%)
Dong, 2018 (n=66) Retrospective
30/36
56±6.5
53.9±5.9
53.9±5.9
24 (80)
27 (75)
27 (75)
21.7±1.8
22.6±2.1
44.5±2.7
45.9±3.6
Left atrium 30 (100%) Myxoma 30 (100%) Left atrium 36 (100%) Myxoma 36 (100%)
Ellouze, 2018 (n=43) Retrospective
20/23
61±12
56±12
56±12
14 (70)
14 (61)
14 (61)
26±4
25±6
3.8±1.8
4.1±1.9
Left atrium 18 (90%) Right atrium 2 (10%) Left atrium 19 (82%) Right atrium 4 (17.3%)
Lou, 2019 (n=50) Retrospective
17/33
55.9±18.2
54.4±17.3
54.4±17.3
12 (70.6)
19 (57.6)
19 (57.6)
NA
NA
NA
NA
Left atrium 40 (80%) Right atrium 8 (16%) Left ventricle 1 (2%) Right ventricle 1 (2%) Myxoma 46 (92%) Lipoma 2 (4%) Rhabdomyoma 1 (2%) Fibroma 1 (2%) Left atrium 40 (80%) Right atrium 8 (16%) Left ventricle 1 (2%) Right ventricle 1 (2%) Myxoma 46 (92%) Lipoma 2 (4%) Rhabdomyoma 1 (2%) Fibroma 1 (2%)
Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy. Data are presented as mean±SD or number. BMI=body mass index. BSA= body surface area. MI=Minimally invasive. MS=Median sternotomy.