loading page

Phylogenetic signal in flowering phenology weakens over elevation in the high Andes of Chile: evidence for evolutionary convergence in a harsh habitat
  • +4
  • Ítalo Tamburrino,
  • Valeria Robles,
  • PAOLA JARA ARANCIO,
  • Pablo Guerrero,
  • Jesús López-Angulo,
  • Jeannine Cavender-Bares,
  • Mary T. Kalin-Arroyo
Ítalo Tamburrino
Universidad de Chile

Corresponding Author:italo.tamburrino@uchile.cl

Author Profile
Valeria Robles
Centro Internacional Cabo de Hornos
Author Profile
PAOLA JARA ARANCIO
Centro Internacional Cabo de Hornos
Author Profile
Pablo Guerrero
Instituto de Ecología y Biodiversidad (IEB)
Author Profile
Jesús López-Angulo
Instituto de Investigación en Cambio Global (IICG-URJC), Universidad Rey Juan Carlos
Author Profile
Jeannine Cavender-Bares
University of Minnesota
Author Profile
Mary T. Kalin-Arroyo
Universidad de Chile
Author Profile

Abstract

In alpine ecosystems, greater overlap in flowering phenology among species at higher elevations could be due to evolutionary convergence among lineages or environmental filtering for taxa preadapted to colder conditions. We hypothesize that the flowering phenology of high alpine communities, subjected to colder and shorter reproductive seasons, is the result of convergence due to strong selective pressure imposed by the environment rather than environmental filtering for conservated traits. To test this hypothesis, we analyzed phylogenetic signal for first flowering date, peak flowering date, flowering duration and thermal sums to first and peak flowering and community phylogenetic structure considering Mean Nearest Taxon Distance (MNTD) and Mean Pairwise Distance (MPD) on four sites encompassing a total of 86 species derived from the subalpine and high alpine in the central Chilean Andes. After discarding possible richness effects on phylogenetic signal, the high alpine sites continued to show significant phylogenetic signal for a smaller number of floral traits than the subalpine sites. This was particularly evident for thermal sums. The two high elevation communities show significant values of SES(MNTD) but not for SES(MPD), indicating clustering related to the tips of the phylogeny. Overall, results suggest that environmental filtering for preadapted lineages is not the main driver of the phylogenetic structure and composition in high alpine communities. Rather, species at higher elevation have been subjected to greater environmental pressures leading to trait convergence. We conclude that phylogenetic conservatism in floral phenology has been overridden by the harsh environmental conditions in the high Andes. The high alpine environment can be seen as an evolutionary promoter rather than a gatekeeper of lineages preadapted to cold conditions.
Submitted to Ecography
Submission Checks Completed
Assigned to Editor
Reviewer(s) Assigned
10 Jul 2024Review(s) Completed, Editorial Evaluation Pending
25 Jul 2024Reviewer(s) Assigned