A two-day-old female Warmblood foal (70 kg) presented with a closed, displaced Salter-Harris type-II fracture of the proximal physis of the left hind first phalanx. For fracture repair four 4.5 mm cortical screws and wire in a figure-of-8 pattern were applied on the lateral and medial aspect of the phalanx, respectively. A 4.5 mm cortical screw was additionally inserted in lag-fashion to engage the lateral metaphyseal spike. Three days postoperatively, medial axis deviation and implant infection were noted and revision surgery was performed. Previous implants were removed and two 4.5 mm transphyseal cortical lag-screws were placed in proximolateral-distomedial and dorsoproximal-plantarodistal direction. Postoperatively, the fracture healed rapidly and the implants were removed 6 weeks later. Nineteen months after implant removal the horse did not show any sign of lameness, despite a shortening of the proximal phalanx compared to the contralateral limb. In cases of postoperative implant instability and infection, implant removal often becomes necessary. However, new implants cannot be placed safely in the previous location. To avoid this problem, this report describes an alternative approach for screw positioning in case of previous implant infection in a Salter-Harris type-II fracture of the proximal physis of the first phalanx.